Isagenix vs Shakeology ~ An Honest Review

Shakeology, Isagenix, Isalean shake, dairy free shake

Let’s face it we’ve all got really busy lives and having time to make a healthy meal in the morning can be a struggle.

—->Enter Meal Replacement Shakes

A simple way to get a fast meal on the go that’s packed with nutrients. Isagenix and Shakeology are on the top of the industry and both shakes are sold as full meal replacement not just protein powder.

So let’s see how they stack up against each other.

The Ingredients

  Isagenix Shakeology
Serving Size (scoops) 2 1
Servings Per Container 14 30
Grams per Serving 61 g 42 g
Amount Per Serving    
Calories 240 160
Total Fat 5 g 2 g
Cholesterol 45 mg 0 g
Sodium 265 mg 150 mg
Potassium 430 mg n/a
Total Carbohydrate 24 g 17 g
Dietary Fiber 8 g 6 g
Sugars 11 g 6 g
Protein 24 g 17 g
$53.27 $129.00
Cost Per Meal $3.81 $4.30



Calling this one a tie. Both companies offer whey and dairy free options.

Isagenix offers the whey options of Creamy Dutch Chocolate, Creamy French Vanilla, Strawberry Cream & Kosher Creamy Vanilla.  Isagenix also offers the dairy free versions of Rich Chocolate, Vanilla Chai & Natural Berry Harvest.

Shakeology offers the whey options of Chocolate, Vanilla & Cafe Latte and the vegan options of Vanilla Vegan & Cafe Latte Vegan.


Isagenix offers more protein than Shakeology with 24 grams versus 17 grams of protein. But, you could add more protein from Shakeology by combining it with skim milk. In the end, this gives Isagenix a slight edge in the protein category.


In terms of fat, Shakeology has far less fat than Isagenix. Isagenix contains 5 grams of fat per serving compared to Shakeology’s 2 grams. That is a pretty big gap and I’d give the win to Shakeology in the fat category.

Click Here To Download

Calories & Fiber

What about the calories? Shakeology only has 140 per serving while Isagenix has 240 per serving. As far as fiber Isagenix totally wins with 7 grams of fiber per serving versus only 3 grams of fiber from Shakeology. If you take all of this into account it’s a draw.


Meal replacement shakes should also have vitamins to help protect the body from free radicals. On this category, Shakeology comes out on top with 300% of the vitamin C daily value compared to only 40% for Isagenix.  
Shakeology offers more Vitamin A as well with 100% versus 50% from Isagenix. 
For calcium, Shakeology has 20% more than the IsaLean Shake. As well as vitamin B6, Shakeology contains of 100% of its daily value, where Isagenix only contains of 70%.

Feeling Full

Before we talk about which one has a better appetite suppressor, a thorough comparison should be done first. Especially of the ingredients because it determines which one performs better than the other to block and manage the appetite.
  The appetite usually is influenced by satiety. So, when a person doesn’t always feel hunger, she or he eats less than another who feels hunger almost all the time.  Satiety doesn’t influence itself.  Instead, it does have strong connection with few kinds of nutrition inside the body.  The more nourished a person feels the less hungry and less strong the cravings will be. 
Take protein for example. When a person eats more protein and less calories, the satiety will last much longer than when she/he eats less protein and more calories. So, when we compare Isagenix and Shakeology, Isagenix gets the edge because it contains more protein than Shakeology.
  Besides protein, fiber also influences how long satiety can last. In this case, again Isagenix is winning because it has more fiber than Shakeology which is 7 grams vs 3 grams.
Quality Control

Isagenix goes out of the way to test all materials they use to make their shakes and other products. They have a “no compromise” policy when it comes to their ingredients so that if you purchase something that has 24 grams of protein it actually will have that amount of protein. I couldn’t find any data on the testing that shakeology does so I’d give the edge here to Isagenix.
The Overall System 

Both companies offer 30 day systems with support coaches to answer nutrition questions. The biggest thing that stood out to me was how Isagenix implements Intermittent fasting into there plans. There are recent scientific articles published about intermittent fasting and the health benefits are incredible. Intermittent fasting can boost your energy, melt visceral fat and more. I’ve included a few article links that speak to intermittent fasting.

How Isagenix Got Ahead Of the Cleansing Curve

Intermittent Fasting Has Benefits Beyond Weight Loss

For this reason I give Isagenix the overall edge here.


Both companies do an incredible job of helping people lose weight and create a healthier lifestyle. In the end, I’d give the edge to Isagenix based on the quality control and the fact that intermittent fasting is part of their overall program.However, Shakeology offers some awesome fitness programs like P90x (which is fantastic) at a slightly additional charge. So, the final decision is on you.


Click Here To Download

Did you get some value from this comparison of the top protein shakes


I hope you did because each week I put my heart into making sure you get some amazing fitness & nutrition tips that will help you look & feel your absolute best.  Healthy can be easy if you have the right tools and strategies!


Wanna Share This Because You Love Sharing Valuable Info?

Each week I try to bring it!  My goal is to provide fresh new content with simple tools that help you look and feel your absolute best!

Healthy Can be Easy!

Connect with me on our Facebook Page by CLICKING HERE

Reach me directly on my cell phone here: Mike Rausa ~ 760-402-8690 (Cell)

Stand Out and Stay Connected… drop a comment below.

You Rock!

Question of the week:   What’s your favorite protein shake?

Join the Conversation.…